11 Brimbal Hill Drive
| Property | Single-family ranch · 2 bedrooms · 1 full / 1 half bath · 1,634 sq ft · 9,375 sq ft lot |
| Prepared for | Donald DeFelice & Carol Finley |
| Effective date | November 12, 2026 |
| Prepared by | Jim Armstrong & Henry Pizzo Co-listing brokers, Aluxety Real Estate |
| Planned listing | Early 2027 |
Henry Pizzo, Owner/Broker · 978-317-6139 · hpizzo@aluxety.com
Aluxety Real Estate · 228 Cabot Street, Beverly, MA 01915
1Executive Summary
11 Brimbal Hill Drive is a single-level North Beverly ranch on a quiet dead-end street with a level, fenced 9,375 sq ft lot. Over the past seven years the owners have replaced most of the big-ticket items a buyer worries about: roof, siding, oil burner, oil tank, water heater, central air, kitchen appliances and flooring, plus an opened-up kitchen/living layout and fresh interior paint.
The four closed sales in the MLS export, adjusted to this home, point to a value of about $717,700. We reconcile slightly below that, to a $690,000–$725,000 range, because two similar 1955 ranches are currently competing at $649,000 and $675,000 (the latter after 41 days and a $15,000 buyer credit), and the home carries a solar lease a buyer must assume.
Because the owners plan to list at the beginning of 2027, these figures are today's value, not a guaranteed launch price. Interest rates and winter inventory will decide whether the right list price in January–March lands nearer the top or the bottom of the range; Section 3 lays out how. We will refresh this analysis two to three weeks before going live.
Key strengths
- One-floor living — 2 bedrooms, full bath, kitchen and living space all on the main level; appeals to downsizers and first-time buyers alike.
- Major systems done — newer roof, siding, central air, oil burner, oil tank and water heater; fewer "year-one" expenses for a buyer.
- Open kitchen/living layout plus a large media/family room — flexible space well beyond the bedroom count.
- Lot and location — larger-than-typical, level, fenced lot on a dead-end street; path to North Beverly Elementary across the street; minutes to Route 128 and North Beverly commuter rail.
- Flood Zone X (unshaded) per RPR — no flood-insurance requirement expected.
2Subject Property Overview
Set back on a short, quiet dead-end street off Brimbal Avenue, this vinyl-sided ranch delivers the kind of easy single-level living that is hard to find in North Beverly. The heart of the home is now open: the wall between the kitchen and living room has come down, joining a spacious eat-in kitchen with the fireplaced living room and its bay window. New kitchen flooring and a full set of new appliances — refrigerator, dishwasher, range and disposal — make the space ready to use on day one.
Both bedrooms and the full bath sit off the living area; the shower was rebuilt when the current owners bought the home. A large media/family room adds real everyday flexibility — a den, playroom or home office — and a half bath sits just inside from the patio. Outside, the level, fenced yard and patio are made for summer evenings, with paved parking for four cars.
Behind the walls, the work has been done: a new shingle roof, new exterior siding, a new oil burner and oil tank, a new water heater and new central air. Two front windows and both bedroom closet doors have also been replaced. Rooftop solar is in place under a monthly payment plan that transfers to the buyer.
| Feature | Detail | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Style / type | Ranch, single-family detached, 1 story with basement · assessor grade Avg, condition Avg-Good | Assessor card / RPR |
| Exterior / roof | Vinyl siding · asphalt shingle gable roof · concrete foundation · hardwood flooring | Assessor card |
| Year built | 1955 | Public record |
| Living area | 1,634 sq ft above grade | Public record / RPR |
| Lot | 9,375 sq ft (0.22 ac), 75 × 125 ft; level, fenced, dead-end street | Deed (Bk 38534 Pg 561) / MLS |
| Rooms / beds / baths | 5 rooms · 2 bedrooms · 1 full + 1 half bath | MLS / RPR |
| Parking | No garage; paved driveway for 4 cars; storage shed | MLS 2019 |
| Basement | Full, 1,068 sq ft unfinished (0 sq ft finished); laundry; bulkhead; sump pump | Public record / MLS 2019 |
| Heat / hot water | Oil forced air — new oil burner and new oil tank; new water heater | Owner list |
| Cooling | Central air (new) — assessor lists 100% A/C | Owner list / Assessor card |
| Fireplace | 1 (living room) | MLS / RPR |
| Recent updates (≈7 yrs) | Roof, siding, kitchen floor, appliances, open layout, interior paint, 2 front windows, closet doors, central air, mechanicals; shower rebuilt at purchase | Owner list |
| Solar | Installed; buyer must assume payments of ≈$152/month | Owner list |
| Flood zone / zoning | Zone X (unshaded) · R10 | RPR |
| Assessment / taxes | FY2026: $663,600 assessed (land $443,100 · building $219,700 · yard items $800) · est. tax $7,174 at $10.81 per $1,000 | Beverly assessor / MLS public record |
| Parcel | Map 68, Lot 101 · Account 9716 · Bk 38534 Pg 561 | Assessor card / deed |
| Occupancy | Owner-occupied | RPR |
| Last sale | 3/26/2019 · $440,000 (listed $449,900; $7,000 seller concession) · 44 days on market. 5/20/2020 deed for $1 added a co-owner (non-arm's-length). | MLS 2019 / public record |
Assessment history
| Fiscal year | Building | Land | Total assessed | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FY2019 | $180,600 | $217,800 | $399,200 | — |
| FY2020 | $194,600 | $229,100 | $424,500 | +6.3% |
| FY2021 | $194,600 | $251,900 | $447,300 | +5.4% |
| FY2022 | $219,600 | $293,500 | $513,900 | +14.9% |
| FY2023 | $219,600 | $333,300 | $553,700 | +7.7% |
| FY2024 | $219,700 | $373,100 | $593,600 | +7.2% |
| FY2025 | $219,700 | $407,200 | $627,700 | +5.7% |
| FY2026 | $219,700 | $443,100 | $663,600 | +5.7% |
Source: City of Beverly assessment history (yard items of $800 included in totals). Since the owners bought in 2019, the assessment has risen 66% — nearly all of it land value, which more than doubled from $217,800 to $443,100. The building value has been flat at about $219,700 since FY2022, so the assessor's figure does not appear to reflect the owners' recent improvements. Massachusetts FY2026 assessments are set as of January 1, 2025, based largely on 2024 sales, so they typically trail the current market. Our $710,000 point estimate is about 7% above the FY2026 assessment, which is consistent with that lag. Assessed value is not market value, and buyers should not treat it as one.
3Local Market Overview — Beverly 01915 Single-Family
Still a seller's market — but cooling at the edges. With under two months of supply and homes selling above list on average, well-priced Beverly homes are still moving quickly. The softening shows up elsewhere: October's median sold price dropped 15.3% month over month, the median active list price slipped 2.5% to $779,000, and RPR's area value index dipped 1.9% for the month while remaining up 3% year over year. Some of the price drop reflects the mix of homes that closed, not just pricing, so we read it as "no longer accelerating" rather than "falling."
Supply has outpaced sales since spring. Active listings rose from 15–16 a month in early 2026 to 39–43 through the summer and fall, while closings have held around 22–24 per month (36 in July). Buyers have more to choose from than they did a year ago, which is exactly why the two competing ranches matter (Section 6).
Season. Beverly's sales volume historically drops sharply from December through March (9–18 closings a month last winter). With a launch planned for early 2027, the home would come to market in that quieter stretch, when buyers are fewer but more motivated and competing listings are scarce. Those buyers are also less patient with pricing that looks ambitious (see the outlook on the next page).
Rates. Our attached materials don't include current mortgage rate data, so we haven't quoted a figure. In practical terms, with this home likely in the high-$600s to low-$700s, monthly payment sensitivity is real for first-time buyers; small rate moves can push buyers toward the lower-priced alternatives listed in Section 6.
Market metrics from the materials provided
| Measure | Value | Source / note |
|---|---|---|
| MLS export — median sale price (4 sold) | $649,650 | Comps export summary |
| MLS export — median sale $/sq ft | $499 | Comps export summary |
| MLS export — average sold $/sq ft (calculated) | $524 | ($511 + $486 + $629 + $471) ÷ 4 |
| MLS export — average days on market, sold (calculated) | 14.75 | (20 + 9 + 13 + 17) ÷ 4; median DTO 8 |
| RPR — 01915 SF sold, last 90 days, similar bed/bath (48 sales) | $860,000 median | $373–$611/sq ft; median $528 — broad mix, not adjusted |
| RPR — recently closed (8), median $/sq ft | $473 | Market Activity page |
| RPR — expired listings, median days | 103 | Expired homes sat 3+ months — the cost of overpricing |
| RPR — median estimated value, 01915 SF | $811,200 | −1.9% month · +3% year |
Sale-to-list ratios for the individual comps could not be calculated: the MLS export shows sale prices but not original list prices for the sold properties.
Looking ahead: listing at the beginning of 2027
This report values the home as of today. A January–March launch changes the backdrop in two ways that matter more than any single comp: how many buyers can afford the payment (interest rates) and how many other homes they can choose from (inventory).
Inventory: fewer homes, fewer buyers
RPR's numbers for Beverly show a clear winter pattern. Last January through March there were only 15–16 active single-family listings a month, versus 39–43 this fall, with just 9–11 sales a month. If that repeats, this home would face far less competition than it would today. The ranches on Dodge Street and Windsor Road will likely have sold or come off the market by then and become data points rather than rivals.
The trade-off is a thinner buyer pool. Buyers shopping in January and February tend to be serious, such as relocations, first-time buyers with expiring leases and downsizers, but there are fewer of them. Supply then ramps up quickly in spring (25 listings in April 2026, 32 in May).
Interest rates: the swing factor
Our materials don't include rate data, so we won't predict where rates go. The direction still matters. At a price near $700,000, a modest drop in rates widens the pool of buyers who qualify and tends to firm up prices. A rise does the opposite: buyers stretch less, look harder at lower-priced alternatives, and negotiate harder on items like the solar assumption.
Rates and inventory tend to move buyer behavior quickly. The list price should be set against the market in front of us at launch, not today's.
Planning scenarios for an early-2027 launch
| Scenario | What it looks like | Planning list price | Likely buyer response |
|---|---|---|---|
| Favorable | Rates ease; winter inventory stays near last year's lows (≈15 listings) | $719,900 | Strong early traffic; competing offers possible; supports the upper half of the range |
| Base case | Rates roughly steady; inventory follows the normal seasonal dip | $699,900 | Steady showings; offers near list within 2–4 weeks |
| Tighter | Rates rise, or inventory stays elevated into winter | $684,900 | Fewer qualified buyers; more negotiation; price to the lower end of the range from day one |
These scenarios are planning tools, not forecasts. They apply today's $690,000–$725,000 value range to different market conditions, and the favorable case only modestly stretches the top of it. Final pricing will be confirmed with fresh comparable sales before listing.
4Comparable Sales Analysis
Ranked list — every property in the MLS export
| Rank | Address | Status | Price | Dist.* | Months since sale | Size diff vs 1,634 | Condition vs subject | Use / weight |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 16 Budleigh Ave | Sold 8/28/26 | $680,000 | ≈0.4 mi | 2.5 | −234 sf (−14%) | Similar (no updates noted); window AC | Primary · 35% |
| 2 | 20 Oakhurst Rd | Sold 9/25/26 | $791,000 | ≈0.5 mi | 1.6 | −87 sf (−5%) | Similar; refinished floors; 2-car garage, no AC | Primary · 35% |
| 3 | 567 Cabot St | Sold 7/15/26 | $619,300 | ≈1.0 mi | 3.9 | −650 sf (−40%) | Superior kitchen/bath (renovated) | Secondary · 15% |
| 4 | 1 Roosevelt Ave | Sold 7/14/26 | $580,000 | ≈1.4 mi | 4.0 | −402 sf (−25%) | Slightly superior kitchen (island) | Secondary · 15% |
| 5 | 161 Dodge St | Active, 41 DOM | $675,000 list | ≈0.6 mi | n/a | −22 sf (−1%) | Unknown; 100-amp service | Competition only |
| 6 | 29 Windsor Rd | Contingent, 25 DTO | $649,000 list | ≈1.2 mi | n/a | +225 sf (+14%) | Superior (new electrical, plumbing) | Competition only |
*Distances are approximate, estimated from the MLS export map and street locations; the export did not include measured radius figures. All four sales closed within 4 months, satisfying the 6-month preference. Cabot St and Roosevelt Ave sit south of Route 128 at roughly the 1-mile edge and are weighted lower for that reason.
Excluded / not-used data
None of the four closed sales showed signs of being distressed, short sales, REO or non-arm's-length transfers in the export. None were excluded from the grid.
| Item | Reason | Category |
|---|---|---|
| 161 Dodge St (active) and 29 Windsor Rd (contingent) | Not closed sales — no confirmed price. Used as competition and as a ceiling check (Section 6), not in the adjustment grid. | Not a closed sale |
| Subject — 3/26/2019 sale, $440,000 | 7½ years old and pre-dates all renovations; not indicative of today's value. | Outlier (dated) |
| Subject — 5/20/2020 deed, $0 consideration | Transfer adding a co-owner (Finley to Finley & DeFelice); no money changed hands. | Non-arm's-length |
| RPR "Distressed" listings (8 in 01915) | Distressed category; individual properties not provided. | Distressed |
| RPR 48-sale "Sold Price Comparison" | Aggregate only — no addresses, sizes or condition; used as market context only. | Not itemized |
Comparable detail
Why selected: Closest sale — off Brimbal Ave like the subject — with the identical 2-bed, 1½-bath layout, no garage and an unfinished basement. Lowest gross adjustment of any comp (5.6%). Differences: smaller house and lot, window AC rather than central, older antique home with a screened porch. Impact: anchors the lower-middle of the range at an adjusted $717,925.
Why selected: Most recent sale, North Beverly, same era, nearly identical size and lot, 2 bedrooms, oil heat. Differences: 2-car attached garage, second full bath, partially finished basement; no central air. MLS codes the style as "Attached – Cape" though remarks and photos describe a single-family Cape — treated as detached. Impact: sets the top of the range at an adjusted $777,535; its garage is a feature the subject cannot match.
Why selected: Recent 2-bedroom, no-garage, unfinished-basement sale showing what a fully renovated small home brings. Differences: 650 sq ft smaller, one bath, window AC, busy Cabot Street frontage; superior renovated kitchen and bath. Impact: supports the middle of the range at an adjusted $678,930, but its large size gap keeps its weight low.
Why selected: 2-bedroom, central-air, no-garage sale on a dead-end street — a "floor" reference. Differences: very small lot, two-story colonial, extra full bath, kitchen with island, partially finished basement, no fireplace; farther south near Beverly Hospital. Impact: lowest adjusted indication ($616,435); highest gross adjustment (15.8%), so lightly weighted.
5Adjustment Grid & Weighted Reconciliation
Adjustments are made to each comparable to make it equal to the subject: a comp feature the subject lacks is subtracted (−); a subject feature the comp lacks is added (+). Rates follow our Massachusetts residential adjustment guidelines: GLA $60/sf · lot $5/sf · full bath $15,000 · half bath $5,000 · 2-car garage $12,000 · central air $7,500 · fireplace $5,000 · partially finished basement $7,500 (≈250 sf × $30).
| Element | Subject | 16 Budleigh Ave | 20 Oakhurst Rd | 567 Cabot St | 1 Roosevelt Ave |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sale price | — | $680,000 | $791,000 | $619,300 | $580,000 |
| Sale date | — | 8/28/26 · $0 | 9/25/26 · $0 | 7/15/26 · $0 | 7/14/26 · $0 |
| Living area (GLA) | 1,634 | +$14,040234 sf × $60 | +$5,22087 sf × $60 | +$39,000650 sf × $60 | +$24,120402 sf × $60 |
| Lot size | 9,375 sf | +$16,3853,277 sf × $5 | +$3,315663 sf × $5 | +$8,1301,626 sf × $5 | +$34,8156,963 sf × $5 |
| Bedrooms | 2 | 2 · $0 | 2 · $0 | 2 · $0 | 2 · $0 |
| Baths | 1F / 1H | 1F/1H · $0 | −$10,0002F/0H: −$15,000 + $5,000 | +$5,0001F/0H: no half bath | −$10,0002F/0H: −$15,000 + $5,000 |
| Garage | None | None · $0 | −$12,0002-car attached | None · $0 | None · $0 |
| Cooling | Central | +$7,500Window AC | +$7,500None | +$7,500Window AC | Central · $0 |
| Fireplace | 1 | 1 · $0 | 1 · $0 | 1 · $0 | +$5,000None |
| Basement finish | Unfinished | Unfinished · $0 | −$7,500Partially finished | Unfinished · $0 | −$7,500Partially finished |
| Kitchen / bath condition | Updated | Similar · $0 | Similar · $0 | −$15,000Fully renovated K & B | −$10,000Updated kitchen w/ island |
| Location | Quiet dead end | Similar · $0 | Similar · $0 | +$15,000Busy Cabot St frontage | Similar · $0 |
| Net adjustment | — | +$37,925 | −$13,465 | +$59,630 | +$36,435 |
| Gross adjustment | — | $37,925 | $45,535 | $89,630 | $91,435 |
| Net % / Gross % | — | 5.6% / 5.6% | −1.7% / 5.8% | 9.6% / 14.5% | 6.3% / 15.8% |
| Adjusted value | — | $717,925 | $777,535 | $678,930 | $616,435 |
All net adjustments are under 15% and all gross adjustments under 25% — the usual benchmarks for a reliable comparable.
Weighted reconciliation
| Comparable | Adjusted value | Weight | Contribution | Reason for weight |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 16 Budleigh Ave | $717,925 | 35% | $251,274 | Closest; same bath layout; lowest gross adjustment |
| 20 Oakhurst Rd | $777,535 | 35% | $272,137 | Most recent; nearly identical size, era, lot |
| 567 Cabot St | $678,930 | 15% | $101,840 | 40% smaller; ≈1 mi; busy street |
| 1 Roosevelt Ave | $616,435 | 15% | $92,465 | Different style, tiny lot; farthest; highest gross |
| Weighted indication | 100% | $717,716 | Rounded: $717,700 |
From indication to opinion of value
The weighted sales indicate $717,700. We place our point estimate a little lower, at about $710,000, and the range at $690,000–$725,000, for three reasons the grid can't capture:
- Competing ranches set a practical ceiling. 161 Dodge St — same 1955 ranch, same 2/1½ layout, 1,612 sq ft, plus a garage — has sat 41 days at $675,000 even with a $15,000 buyer credit. 29 Windsor Rd, a renovated 1955 ranch, needed 25 days to go under agreement at $649,000.
- Solar lease. A buyer must qualify for and assume a ≈$152/month obligation. Per our guidelines, leased solar typically adds little or no value and can narrow the buyer pool or slow underwriting.
- Season and momentum. Rising fall inventory, a month-over-month dip in local value indices, and a winter launch window with fewer active buyers.
6Active & Pending Competition
The most direct competitor — almost a twin on paper. Sellers are now offering up to $15,000 toward buyer closing costs on a full-price offer, which effectively prices it near $660,000. In a market where the median home goes under agreement in about a week, 41 days says buyers have already passed on it at this price. Our subject's advantages: quiet dead-end street versus Dodge Street traffic, larger lot, and new roof/siding/mechanicals. Its advantages: a garage, gas heat and a walk-out basement. Takeaway: buyers will compare the two directly; we need a clear reason for every dollar above Dodge's net price.
A renovated 1955 ranch south of Route 128 that took 25 days to find a buyer at $649,000. Its final sale price isn't known yet; when it closes, it will be an important data point for this home.
Risks of overpricing
- Above roughly $725,000, this home is priced over every comparable ranch and into the territory of larger 3-bedroom homes — buyers will tour it, then buy elsewhere.
- RPR shows expired 01915 listings sat a median of 103 days. A winter listing that goes stale tends to carry into the spring market as "old inventory," and price cuts usually net less than the right price on day one.
- The first two weeks bring the most motivated buyers; pricing within the range is what converts that attention into offers.
7Pricing Strategy Recommendations
- Buyer response: strongest — priced just above Dodge St's list with a better street and newer systems; likely multiple showings opening weekend.
- Market time: ≈ 7–14 days.
- Negotiation: realistic chance of competing offers; expected sale ≈ $690,000–$710,000.
- Trade-off: relies on competition to push price; less room if only one offer arrives.
- Buyer response: solid — under the $700K search break and below the adjusted North Beverly sales.
- Market time: ≈ 14–30 days.
- Negotiation: offers near list; expected sale ≈ $695,000–$715,000.
- Why: balances the comp evidence with the competition and season.
- Buyer response: narrower — tests the top of the range and RPR's estimate.
- Market time: ≈ 30–60+ days; may carry into spring.
- Negotiation: expect inspection and solar-lease pushback; a reduction is likely if no offer in 3 weeks.
- Likely outcome: ≈ $695,000–$710,000, after more time.
Launch recommendations
- Lead with the work that's been done. A one-page update sheet (roof, siding, burner, tank, water heater, central air, appliances) with dates and receipts turns "1955" into "move-in ready."
- Get ahead of the solar. Have the agreement, remaining term, monthly amount, transfer process and production history in the listing packet from day one.
- Stage the media room as a family room or office so buyers see flexible living space, not a single-purpose room.
- Plan an early-week offer review after the first weekend of showings to give buyers a clear deadline.
8Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities & Risks
Strengths
- Single-level living
- New roof, siding, mechanicals, central air
- Open kitchen/living; large family/media room
- 9,375 sf level, fenced lot on a dead end
- Near North Beverly Elementary, Route 128, commuter rail
- Flood Zone X
Weaknesses
- Two bedrooms only
- No garage
- Oil heat (newer equipment, but many buyers prefer gas)
- Basement treated as unfinished
- Kitchen cabinets/counters not noted as updated
Opportunities
- Appeal to downsizers seeking one-floor living
- Media room as office or potential 3rd-bedroom-style use (buyer to verify code requirements)
- Room on the lot for a future garage, subject to zoning and permits
- Solar may reduce electric bills — document the savings
Risks
- Solar lease transfer — lender and buyer acceptance
- Rising inventory and seasonal slowdown
- Direct competition from 161 Dodge St
- Removed wall — buyers may ask about permits
- Unknown roof/siding/AC install dates
Influencing factors checklist
| Factor | Assessment |
|---|---|
| Deferred maintenance | None reported; major systems replaced in last ~7 years. Not yet verified by walkthrough photos (see open items). |
| Market softening | Mild — inventory up, monthly indices down slightly; still a seller's market at 1.95 months. |
| Floor plan / functional obsolescence | 2-bed count with large media room is a modest limitation for families; open layout is a plus. |
| Flood zone | Zone X (unshaded) — minimal risk. |
| HOA | None. |
| Over-improvement | No — updates are system-level and in line with the neighborhood. |
| Economic / financing | Rate sensitivity in this price range; solar assumption adds an underwriting step. |
9Final Opinion of Value
These conclusions reflect the market as of November 12, 2026. With a planned early-2027 launch, we will confirm the range and list price against fresh sales, current rates and live inventory before listing.
Four closed sales within four months, two of them in North Beverly and within about half a mile, adjust to a weighted $717,700 with modest adjustments. Two directly competing 1955 ranches and the solar lease temper that figure, leading to a point estimate near $710,000 and a recommended list price of $699,900.
Why "Moderate" rather than "High": the export contains only four closed sales; distances are estimated; the solar terms are unconfirmed; and comparable condition is based on short MLS remarks. Resolving the open items below could tighten the range and move confidence to High.
Open items — information that could shift the value
- Solar agreement: lease vs. PPA vs. loan, provider, remaining term, escalator, buyout, and transfer requirements.
- Install years for roof, siding, central air, burner and tank; permits for the wall removal.
- Exact MLS distances to each comp; confirmation that 20 Oakhurst Rd is detached; exact lot size of 16 Budleigh Ave.
- Final sale price of 29 Windsor Rd when it closes, and the outcome of 161 Dodge St.
- Refresh before the early-2027 launch: new closed sales, current mortgage rates and active inventory.
AAssumptions
- Subject GLA is 1,634 sq ft above grade (public record), including the media/family room; it has not been measured.
- Subject basement is treated as unfinished (assessor and public record: 1,068 sf unfinished, 0 sf finished), although the 2019 MLS listed it as partially finished.
- Subject condition is rated "Updated/Good" based on the owner's improvement list, the assessor's Avg-Good rating, and exterior photos.
- "Side exterior of house" on the owner's list means new siding; the assessor card confirms vinyl siding, replacing the wood shingles shown in 2019.
- Owner-listed improvements were completed within the last ~7 years, with the shower done at the 2019 purchase.
- Solar is treated as a leased or financed system with no positive value adjustment, per the guidelines; it is reflected in reconciliation, not in the grid.
- No time (market-conditions) adjustment: all sales closed within 4 months and area indices are roughly flat (+3% year, −1.9% month).
- Distances are approximate, estimated from the MLS export map and street locations.
- 16 Budleigh Ave lot is 0.14 acres ≈ 6,098 sq ft; the export shows "0 Acres (0.14 SqFt)," a data-entry error.
- 20 Oakhurst Rd is a detached single-family home despite the "Attached – Cape" MLS code (remarks describe a North Beverly Cape on an 8,712 sf lot).
- Comp condition comes from truncated MLS remarks: Budleigh and Oakhurst similar; Cabot superior kitchen/bath (−$15,000); Roosevelt superior kitchen with island (−$10,000).
- 567 Cabot St is inferior in location due to busy-street frontage (+$15,000, ≈2.4%), within the guideline's location-influence category.
- Partially finished basements are valued at a flat $7,500 (≈250 sf × $30 default) because finished square footage was not provided.
- Lot adjusted at $5/sq ft for all differences, per the adjustment schedule in the project instructions.
- Full bath $15,000 and half bath $5,000 (guideline defaults); a 2F/0H comp versus the subject's 1F/1H nets to −$10,000.
- 2-car garage at $12,000 (top of the $10K–$12K schedule).
- No adjustment for heating fuel (oil vs gas), age, or style; the guidelines say not to adjust for age alone.
- No seller concessions on the sold comps, since none appear in the export.
- All four sales are arm's-length, since the export shows no distressed, REO, short-sale or related-party indicators.
- Weights (35/35/15/15) reflect proximity, recency, size similarity and gross adjustment.
- Pricing-tier market times are estimates based on RPR median days (7–10), the comps' DOM (9–20), and the competing listings' DOM (25–41).
Important Disclosure
This report is a Comparative Market Analysis / broker price opinion prepared by Jim Armstrong, a licensed Massachusetts real estate broker (License #9074205) and REALTOR® with Aluxety Real Estate, for a co-listing with Henry Pizzo, Owner/Broker of Aluxety Real Estate. It is not an appraisal. It was not prepared by a licensed appraiser — Jim Armstrong does not hold a Massachusetts appraisal license — and this analysis should not be used in place of an appraisal for lending, tax, legal or estate purposes.
Values are estimates based on market data available as of November 12, 2026, including MLS Property Information Network data, Realtors Property Resource® (RPR) data, public records and information provided by the owners, none of which is guaranteed. Market conditions can change rapidly. The final sale price will depend on buyer demand, financing, property condition and negotiation.
Broker · Aluxety Real Estate
978-394-6736 · jarmstrong@aluxety.com
Henry Pizzo
Owner/Broker · Aluxety Real Estate
978-317-6139 · hpizzo@aluxety.com
228 Cabot Street, Beverly, MA 01915

